« Like Minds | Main | Youth is Wasted on the Young »
November 21, 2005
Allure
I am not a girly-girl who hugs and kisses everyone she meets. I am not dressed in head-to-toe pink, nor do I have a tiny dog. I wasn’t a cheerleader. I wasn’t a sorority girl. I don’t have a high voice or a convertible. I don’t speak with a tremendous amount of slang and when I do, it sounds forced.
Mother Goosemouse posted about forced and assumed intimacy, and it made me think a lot about my social cues and expectations. I don’t feel comfortable being embraced with an open-armed squeal. Instead, I am self-conscious and don’t wish to be touched. A firm handshake is sufficient.
But, the truth is that frequently I wish I were more of a girly-girl. I wish I could sling my arm around a friend with abandon, or giggle to a group of gals about nothing. I have started to wear pink more frequently. I tried out for cheerleader both in junior high and college. I made the finals for both. But in the end I was told that I was more of a dancer than a cheerleader, and we didn’t have dance teams for either school.
In high school, we didn’t have cheerleaders, but I started a spirit club and bought a black pleated tennis skirt as the closest approximation to a cheerleader skirt that I could find. Our colors were yellow and black, so that would have worked, except my other spirit-mates thought it would be cooler to wear white T-shirts and plaid boxer shorts. Then the steam hissed out of our club when it was apparent that many of the interested girls couldn’t dance (and I didn’t want to exclude them because I didn’t want to hurt their feelings!) but most importantly because one of the most enthusiastic girls got into a car accident that paralyzed her.
I thought about rushing a Sorority in college, but the people I met at Rush absolutely ignored me. I clearly didn't fit in. (Why? I wish I knew!) Fortunately, one of my upperclassman advisors brought me to the Rush for his co-ed Fraternity and I felt right at home there. That is the Society for which I had a Convention weekend before last. These people welcomed me warmly and I felt comfortable.
But sometimes I daydream about if things had been different. I wonder if what would have happened had I made cheerleader, or made a friend in a Sorority. Would I feel more comfortable around other women than I do now? Or would I just have felt uncomfortable because I am not a girly-girl?
What is the allure? Why would I even want to become something with which I am not comfortable?
I guess it is because the more exclusive something is, the more attractive it becomes. Those blonde convertible-driving Sorority cheerleaders seem perfect. I know their lives probably aren’t, but from the surface everything seems fantastic. It appears that many of them grew up to be the mothers at my son’s preschool. I feel the same disconnect with them than I did with the “popular kids” back in school.
When I look at pictures of my college-self during Society cocktail parties, I look the part. I am attractive with long blonde hair and a hot body. Alas, I went to college during the grunge days, so my everyday attire wasn’t flattering to the body that I wish I still had. When I didn’t make cheerleader, I started playing hockey. When I wasn’t dressed up for a special event, I was pretty androgynous.
But appearances only get you so far. I wonder what it is that makes one comfortable with the physical contact and open glee. I’ve always been more “serious” and less “frivolous.” But I have wanted to dabble in the fluffy. I read silly magazines like Cosmo, Glamour, and Lucky. I watch TV shows like Laguna Beach, the Real World, and O.C. But when approached in a touchy-feely way, I back off. It is uncomfortable to me. And yet at the same time, I want to be part of the fold.
Perhaps it is because while I was growing up, I thought I had to be serious to get a good job and earn good money. But now that I am a SAHM, that means to an end no longer exists. I’ve gotten my degrees. I have a resume. But I change diapers instead. So already, I am questioning my identity, so why not question my social stance as well?
I don’t grapple with these questions in a heavy way very frequently. They don’t keep me up at night. I just think about it rather superficially as I watch my guilty pleasures, or observe kids at my alma maters. I do interviews for both my high school and college alma maters, and it is frequently surreal to remember myself in their shoes.
Last weekend’s trip back to college of course stirred up many memories, and this week I am doing interviews for prospective students. Then since I am on the Board of Trustees for my high school, I am frequently out there on campus and will be doing interviews for them in a couple weeks.
For the most part, I do live in the present. But since I have heavy involvement to aspects of my past, I can’t help but reminisce sometimes, especially when it correlates to something someone has already written, like Mother Goosemouse’s musings.
UPDATE: I did some more thinking about this. There are definitely people that I enjoy embracing, and not just family members. People who I feel comfortable with in conversation can be people I am comfortable with greeting in a physical way.
One of my highlights of BlogHer was getting a hug from JenB. It was wonderful and comfortable to me because I felt as though I knew her through her writings. There are several other people about whom I would feel the same way, just based on our online friendships.
Of course, we get to know each other more quickly online than we would in person, so it makes sense that this comfort level would exist, but it is funny nonetheless since there are many "in person" friends who I enjoy as talking buddies but wouldn't necessarily want to be locked in a hug with!
Posted by karianna at November 21, 2005 06:04 AM
Comments
Kari, I feel the same way about my Internet friends - of both the PIM and the bloggy varieties. And like you, I'm still a bit mystified about the differences between hugging my digital friends vs. my analog ones. Are we more honest online, and having already laid ourselves bare in our blogs (or message boards, in the case of my PIMs), does it seem silly to put up walls once we are face to face? I guess we shall see at BlogHer 2006!
Posted by: Julie at November 21, 2005 03:24 PM
Julie: It is funny. BlogHer 2006 will be fun because I've "gotten to know" many more bloggers since my appearance at BlogHer 2005. Some people that I met with a handshake at BH05 are now people I feel "close" to, and then there are folks like you who I haven't met face to face, and yet I feel like we know each other. It will be interesting. :)
Posted by: Kari at November 21, 2005 04:00 PM
Well, there'll always be a hug from me, for you, if you want (or need) one. I'm reliably informed that I "give good hug". It's a bonus, and no charge. ;)
Posted by: Koan Bremner at November 30, 2005 10:23 PM